Mon, 06 Dec 2021

The French oil and gas giant Total knew how harmful its activities were for the climate in the early 1970s but chose to keep the information under wraps, French researches have learned.

Using internal company documents and interviews with former company executives, three historians on Wednesday published the findings of their work in the peer-reviewed journal Global Environment Change.

In 1971, an internal magazine by Total explained that burning fossil fuels caused the release of "enormous amounts of carbon dioxide" in the atmosphere, the consequences of which were potentially "catastrophic".

However the company, now rebranded as TotalEnergies, "began promoting doubt regarding the scientific basis for global warming by the late 1980s," the researchers found.

Over the next 17 years, its internal magazine never again mentioned the issue of climate change. Total and Elf, the company it merged with in 1999, perceived the science as a "very real threat" to their business, the researchers added.

Sowing doubt

In the early 1990s, ahead of the Rio Earth Summit, Total's environmental director, Jean-Philippe Caruette, wrote in the company's magazine: "There is no certainty about the impact of human activities [on global warming], including the combustion of fossil fuels."

However by the late 1990s, when the UN's IPCC climate experts published their first report and the Kyoto Protocol was adopted, Total publicly accepted climate science.

UN biodiversity talks in China end in funding pledges to reduce loss of species France leads charge to label nuclear power as 'green' under EU taxonomy rules

They did this while still minimising the climate emergency by promoting policies that "delayed fossil fuel control" and increasing their investments in oil and gas production, the researchers found.

A new strategy followed in 2006, when Total hosted a conference on climate change and its CEO acknowledged the reality of climate change and the conclusions of the IPCC.


This year saw the birth of TotalEnergies, renamed in a bid to promote a shift towards renewable energy, which the company said would account for 20 percent of investment in 2021.

However it's also projected an increase of 50 percent of oil and gas between 2015 and 2030, the researchers said.

In a statement sent to AFP, a spokesman for Total said the company had not seen the study and therefore could not respond.

The trio behind the research was Christophe Bonneuil, of the CNRS, Pierre-Louis Choquet, a sociologist at Sciences Po, and Benjamin Franta, a researcher in history at Stanford University in the United States.

Their work follows similar revelations about US oil giant ExxonMobil and Royal Dutch Shell - a pattern that shows oil and gas giants have been undermining confidence in climate science despite being informed by their own scientists of the dire risks posed by rising temperatures.

Originally published on RFI

More Brazil News

Access More

Sign up for Brazil News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!